‘South African miners reach $400m settlement for lung diseases with mining companies

ORKNEY, SOUTH AFRICA - OCTOBER 18 : Gold miners pray underground before beginning a shift at the Great Noligwa Mine, run by Anglo Gold. This mine has a dust reduction system in place in hopes of lowering the rate of silicosis. Doctors have thus far found that while silica dust is reducing, silicosis remains constant, possibly owing to the latency of the disease. South African Gold miners are particularly vulnerable to contracting TB because of the small, poorly ventilated work and living conditions, high rates of HIV and high rates of silicosis, a lung disease often found in miners that increases the chance of having active TB. This project was funded by a grant from the International Reporting Project at Johns Hopkins University SAIS.(Photo by David Rochkind/Getty Images)

South African gold producers agreed a five-billion-rand (400 million US dollars) class action settlement on Thursday with law firms representing thousands of miners who contracted the fatal lung diseases silicosis and tuberculosis, officials said on Thursday.

The most far-reaching class action settlement ever reached in South Africa follows a long legal battle by miners to win compensation for illnesses they say they contracted over decades because of negligence in health and safety.

The six companies involved had already set aside the settlement amount in provisions in previous financial statements and it should not affect future earnings, unless the number of claimants who come forward exceed the current provisions.

Estimates for the number of potential claimants range from tens of thousands to hundreds of thousands. Three smaller gold producers are not party to the settlement and the class action against them will continue.

Former gold miner Thulani Bitsha, who contracted silicosis while working underground, stands in the doorway to his home near Bizana in South Africa’s impoverished Eastern Cape Province, March 7, 2012. /Reuters Photo

The class action suit was launched six years ago on behalf of miners suffering from silicosis, an incurable disease caused by inhaling silica dust from gold-bearing rocks.

It causes shortness of breath, a persistent cough and chest pains, and also makes people highly susceptible to tuberculosis.

Almost all the claimants are black miners from South Africa and neighboring countries such as Lesotho. Critics say they were not provided with adequate protection during and after apartheid rule ended in 1994.

The settlement is broken into three parts and a trust will have 12 years to track down the claimants and distribute the funds – no easy task as many are in remote rural areas and may do not have proper medical and other records.

Out of the five billion rand, 845 million rand will be used to cover the administration expenses of the trust over the 12-year period and 370 million rand will be paid to the law firms.

The remainder is for compensation and the final total will depend on the number of claims that are processed.

“If there are more claimants the actuaries have estimated, then that five billion number could increase. If there are less then it will decrease,” Graham Briggs, who chaired the Occupational Lung Disease Working Group, a unit put together by the six companies, told a news conference.

In addition to the anticipated settlement payout, there is also close to four billion rand in a compensation fund which companies have been contributing to for years.

Former gold miner Dabula Mnyaka scans a notice board before a registration meeting in Bizana in South Africa’s impoverished Eastern Cape Province, March 7, 2012. /Reuters Photo

The companies involved are Harmony Gold, Gold Fields, African Rainbow Minerals, Sibanye-Stillwater, AngloGold Ashanti and Anglo American South Africa. The latter no longer has gold assets but historically was a bullion producer.

Same ball park

“Our numbers differ slightly from the industry, we think there are more claimants and that the numbers will be higher than what they anticipate. While we differ slightly with the industry we think it’s all in the same ball park,” said Richard Spoor, one of the lawyers representing the mine workers.

It is the first class-action settlement in South Africa involving so many companies and claimants.

“The settlement is the product of commercial negotiation and compromise, but we believe this is a beneficial settlement,” said Carina du Toit, a lawyer with the Legal Resources Center, one of the law groups representing the workers.

Former gold miner Senzele Silewise diagnosed with silicosis talks to paralegals in Bizana in South Africa’s impoverished Eastern Cape Province, March 7, 2012. /VCG Photo‍

Abrahams Kiewitz Inc and Richard Spoor Attorneys and two other companies also represented the mine workers.

The parties said the compromise settlement was preferable for all concerned rather than a lengthy and expensive litigation process, and would enable the claimants to receive compensation and relief for their conditions more quickly.

The settlement still needs approval by the Johannesburg High Court before being implemented.

In recent years the gold mining industry has taken precautions to prevent its workers from contracting silicosis, including the use of masks and other measures.

Source(s): Reuters